Does Every Tank Really Need an Algae Eater?

About Tank Algae

Most fish tanks develop algae, and if left unchecked, it can lead to strong smells, murky green or brown water or even health problems for your resident fish. Algae are simple aquatic plants that grow best in water with significant uneaten food or waste, and different types of algae may develop. Some algae is free-floating, while others may appear as a scummy or filmy layer on the sides of the tank or on tank features such as rocks, gravel or wood. The largest algae may even have a grass-like or seaweed-like structure. While some small amount of algae is natural and to be expected, if the problem is growing out of control, it may be time to consider an algae eater.

Do You Need an Algae Eater?

There are many ways to control algae in the tank, and you do not necessarily need an algae eater to combat the problem. Because an algae eater means one more fish or creature in the tank, its needs have to be considered as well, and it may be best to control the algae in other ways, such as…

• Choosing a higher quality filter that will remove algae from the water, and keeping the filter clean so it operates at peak efficiency.
• Adjusting fish feeding schedules and amounts to minimize uneaten food that can encourage algae growth. Higher quality food can also lead to less waste.
• Opting for more live plants that will out-compete with algae to take advantage of the waste products and nutrients in the water.
• Cleaning the tank more frequently, including wiping off the glass, vacuuming gravel and changing water to minimize algae.
• Turning off tank lights for several hours each night so algae cannot photosynthesize. Fish do not need the light, and less light will mean less algae growth.

If there is still a significant algae problem after taking several steps to control it, it may be time to bring an algae eater home.

Choosing the Right Algae Eater

Algae eaters are specific organisms that thrive on a diet of algae. Not all organisms eat all types of algae, however, and it is critical to choose the type of algae eater that will make meals of the specific algae in your tank. The most common algae eaters include snails, shrimp, clams and even some fish, such as specific types of catfish or plecos. To be sure you are choosing the best algae eater for your tank…

• Consider the type of algae you want to control, and choose an eater best known to eat that type of algae. This will give you the best results with reducing the algae in your tank.
• Choose an eater that will be compatible with other fish and organisms in your tank so there are no problems with territoriality or aggression.
• Take note of your tank size and choose an algae eater suitable to control the problem. In a large tank, you may need several algae eaters to adequately reduce the algae.
• Be sure the algae eater will thrive in your tank's conditions, including the water quality, temperature, tank size and pH level.

Above all, avoid getting an algae eater before you have algae for them to eat. They need enough algae to survive, and if your tank does not have any, getting an algae eater is not a technique to be sure you don't develop an algae problem. When the problem is there, however, they can be a welcome – and hungry! – addition to your tank.